There has been a lot of talk in recent years about the dangers of children being hit by spots, but there have been few warnings about the dangers of screaming. However, the latest research shows that screaming in children can be like that harmful, such as spank .
A study published in Child development reports that shouting and harsh verbal discipline have serious consequences for children. Researchers have found that the screams grow behavior problems and depressive symptoms in adolescents.
When parents scream, they often do so because they have lost their temper. As a result, they are more likely to make offensive comments or insult their children. This can seriously affect a child’s self-image.
The two-year study concluded that the effects of severe and frequent verbal discipline were comparable to the negative effects of corporal punishment.
As children reach adolescence, an age when they begin to develop an identity separate from their parents, they may be particularly vulnerable to harsh discipline. The study found that children in this age group who were subjected to severe verbal discipline were more likely to exhibit aggressive and violent behavior.
Despite the consequences of screaming, almost all parents scream sometimes. A study published in 2003 in Marriage and family diary found that 90% of parents said they screamed, screamed or screamed at their children in the last year. Among families with children over the age of 7, almost 100% of participants admitted to screaming at their children.
Why screaming doesn’t work
Screaming is not only harmful to children, but it is not an effective discipline strategy. Here are some reasons why you might want to think twice before raising your voice:
- Shouting worsens behavior problems. The cry creates a perpetual cycle: the more parents scream, the worse the children behave, which in turn leads to more cries. To interrupt this cycle, it is important to commit to using alternative disciplinary practices that do not involve screaming.
- Children become numb at volume. The first time you scream at a child, it is likely to get their attention. But the louder you shout, the less effective it will be. When children live in houses where they scream frequently, they get used to it.
- The shouts increase the frustration of the parents. If you are already frustrated with your child’s behavior, the cries will only increase his arousal level. Raising your voice can quickly turn a slight irritation into absolute anger. It also increases the likelihood that you will make offensive comments or use harsh criticism.
- Children learn that screaming is a good way to deal with conflict. When you scream, you model how to deal with anger and conflict. Your child will imitate these behaviors when dealing with colleagues and siblings.
- Shouting does not involve surrender. Shouting at a child, «Stop doing this,» he doesn’t show her what to do. Children need to learn skills that help them regulate their emotions and manage their behavior so that they do not repeat the same mistakes.
- Loss of control means loss of respect. It is difficult for children to instill a lot of trust and respect in someone who insults or screams at them. Sometimes children think, «If you can’t control yourself, how can you control me?» Therefore, they are less likely to want to thank you and less likely to appreciate your opinion.
- The shout doesn’t work. In the end, the shouts don’t work. If so, parents should not do so much. However, most parents find that they scream more often, rather than less. Other consequences, such as take privileges , can be much more effective in controlling a child’s behavior.
Most parents do not want to shout at their children, but they do so out of frustration. When children do not listen or when they break the rules, you need a plan on how to discipline without shouting .